Here is our illustrious Hall of Fame for past winners. As these are lifetime awards there can be no repeats for a category, though a single character may win in multiple categories. If you are nominating a character for one of these awards, do not nominate a past winner as they will not make the list.

Least Competent Henchman

• 2020 The Dufflepuds from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2019 Puzzle from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2018 Fezzik from The Princess Bride
• 2017 Mr. Smee from Peter Pan

Most Epic Hero

• 2020 Reepicheep from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2019 Westley from The Princess Bride
• 2018 Edmund Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2017 Peter Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2016 Robin Hood from The Adventures of Robin Hood

Most Epic Heroine

• 2020 Hermione from Harry Potter
• 2019 Cinder from The Lunar Chronicles
• 2018 Aravis from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2017 Lucy Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia

Most Faithful Friend

• 2020 Puddleglum from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2019 Iko from The Lunar Chronicles
• 2018 Little John from The Adventures of Robin Hood
• 2017 Inigo Montoya from The Princess Bride
• 2016 Reepicheep from The Chronicles of Narnia

Most Magnificent Dragon

• 2020 Clefspeare from Dragons in Our Midst
• 2019 Saphira from Eragon
• 2018 Eustace from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2017 Toothless from How to Train Your Dragon

Most Mischievous Imp

• 2020 Kalmar from Wingfeather Saga
• 2019 Crispin Beasley from The Afterverse
• 2018 Peter Pan from Peter Pan
• 2017 The Weasley Twins from Harry Potter

Most Nefarious Villain

• 2020 Voldemort from Harry Potter
• 2019 Death in Life from Tales of the Goldstone Wood
• 2018 Queen Levana from The Lunar Chronicles
• 2017 Shift from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2016 The White Witch from The Chronicles of Narnia

Strangest Character

• 2020 Miracle Max from The Princess Bride
• 2019 Luna Lovegood from Harry Potter
• 2018 Peet Wingfeather from The Wingfeather Saga
• 2017 The Mad Hatter from Alice in Wonderland
• 2016 Puddleglum from The Chronicles of Narnia

Silver Tongue

• 2020 Eanrin from Tales of the Goldstone Wood
• 2019 Lady of the Green Kirtle from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2018 Howl from Howl’s Moving Castle
• 2017 Mo from Inkheart
• 2016 The Sorting Hat from Harry Potter

Wisest Conselor

• 2020 Halt from Ranger’s Apprentice
• 2019 Remus Lupin from Harry Potter
• 2018 Professor Kirke from The Chronicles of Narnia
• 2017 Professor Hamilton from Dragons in Our Midst
• 2016 Aslan from The Chronicles of Narnia

Retired Categories

Best Fantasy Mount

• 2016 Bree from The Horse and His Boy

Best Fantasy Weapon

• 2016 Peter’s sword from The Chronicles of Narnia

Best Redemption Story

• 2016 Edmund Pevensie from The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe

Most Heartwrenching Death

• 2016 Aslan from The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe

The list goes ever on and on…

We hope you enjoyed this grand list of award winning characters. Check back every year when the new winners are posted to see if your favorite character wins undying glory in the Silmaril vault. And if you’ve not read about some of these characters, be sure to check out the books they appear in.