Least Competent Henchman
- 2020 The Dufflepuds from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2019 Puzzle from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2018 Fezzik from The Princess Bride
- 2017 Mr. Smee from Peter Pan
Most Epic Hero
- 2020 Reepicheep from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2019 Westley from The Princess Bride
- 2018 Edmund Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2017 Peter Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2016 Robin Hood from The Adventures of Robin Hood
Most Epic Heroine
- 2020 Hermione from Harry Potter
- 2019 Cinder from The Lunar Chronicles
- 2018 Aravis from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2017 Lucy Pevensie from The Chronicles of Narnia
Most Faithful Friend
- 2020 Puddleglum from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2019 Iko from The Lunar Chronicles
- 2018 Little John from The Adventures of Robin Hood
- 2017 Inigo Montoya from The Princess Bride
- 2016 Reepicheep from The Chronicles of Narnia
Most Magnificent Dragon
- 2020 Clefspeare from Dragons in Our Midst
- 2019 Saphira from Eragon
- 2018 Eustace from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2017 Toothless from How to Train Your Dragon
Most Mischievous Imp
- 2020 Kalmar from Wingfeather Saga
- 2019 Crispin Beasley from The Afterverse
- 2018 Peter Pan from Peter Pan
- 2017 The Weasley Twins from Harry Potter
Most Nefarious Villain
- 2020 Voldemort from Harry Potter
- 2019 Death in Life from Tales of the Goldstone Wood
- 2018 Queen Levana from The Lunar Chronicles
- 2017 Shift from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2016 The White Witch from The Chronicles of Narnia
Strangest Character
- 2020 Miracle Max from The Princess Bride
- 2019 Luna Lovegood from Harry Potter
- 2018 Peet Wingfeather from The Wingfeather Saga
- 2017 The Mad Hatter from Alice in Wonderland
- 2016 Puddleglum from The Chronicles of Narnia
Silver Tongue
- 2020 Eanrin from Tales of the Goldstone Wood
- 2019 Lady of the Green Kirtle from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2018 Howl from Howl’s Moving Castle
- 2017 Mo from Inkheart
- 2016 The Sorting Hat from Harry Potter
Wisest Conselor
- 2020 Halt from Ranger’s Apprentice
- 2019 Remus Lupin from Harry Potter
- 2018 Professor Kirke from The Chronicles of Narnia
- 2017 Professor Hamilton from Dragons in Our Midst
- 2016 Aslan from The Chronicles of Narnia
Retired Categories
Best Fantasy Mount
- 2016 Bree from The Horse and His Boy
Best Fantasy Weapon
- 2016 Peter’s sword from The Chronicles of Narnia
Best Redemption Story
- 2016 Edmund Pevensie from The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe
Most Heartwrenching Death
- 2016 Aslan from The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe